The Other Side of the Follow-Up

I built a methodology out of knowing how to handle silences. Now I'm on the wrong side of one.

Leigh Sutton
Leigh Sutton Corporate lifer. Aspiring free agent. 4 min read
An open notebook with a pen beside a coffee mug on a reflective table.
Photo by Mahmoud Zakariya on Pexels

July 8. Inbox at 7:08. Twenty-four days in one column, sixteen in the other. Twenty-three days left in July.

I have been in enterprise account management for 24 years. The central skill, the one I would list first if someone asked what this work actually requires, is knowing how to handle the gap between conversations. Most accounts do not go sideways in meetings. They go sideways in the silences between meetings. I know this the way I know how to parallel park: it is below the level of thought now, but it was real work once.

Here is what I used to do: I sent the follow-up. Not aggressive. Not performative. Deliberate. A clean note at day seven if I had not heard anything. A phone call at day fourteen if the note went unanswered. I was not nagging. I was keeping the thread alive. Accounts that go quiet tend to churn, and I recognized the pattern earlier than almost anyone I worked with.

I know this because I wrote it down. Three case studies in a document I keep coming back to. The $2.2 million renewal in 2019. The telecom account in 2021. The conference dinner in 2022 where I sketched the whole thing on a cocktail napkin. The pattern is the same across all three: read the silence early, move before it hardens into a decision you cannot reverse.

Here is what I have now: two people who have not responded to follow-ups I sent twenty-four days ago and sixteen days ago respectively. I am not going to send a third. I named seven and fourteen as the right windows. I met both. The methodology I built out of 24 years of not letting things go silent does not include a third contact inside the same month. You learn when to stop being the one keeping the thread.

But I have never been on this side of it before. I have always been the vendor. The one following up, the one trying to read whether the quiet is benign or just slow. Now I am the one waiting, and I am discovering that it feels different than I expected. More uncomfortable than I expected, or uncomfortable in a different way. I have not figured out which.


I built July as a milestone in the backward map. First-conversations month. That is what the spreadsheet says under the column I called Real Calendar. I did not specify what happens if the conversations do not materialize by July 31. I just wrote: July. Conversations.

It is July 8. Twenty-three days.

I still think both contacts will respond. Not because I have evidence, but because I know enterprise timelines, and neither of these silences is outside the range of normal for a relationship that has been dormant for several years. I know what it looks like from the other inbox: full, behind, the note from someone you actually want to hear from sitting there flagged while you handle the three things on fire. I have done this to people. I know what it means and what it does not mean.

But the milestone exists, and I built it, and I am watching the days.


What I have been doing while I wait: walking the dog at 7:30. Checking the inbox at 7:08, which I realize I have been doing for seventy-four mornings in a row now, which is a number I did not expect to notice. Working on the document, which is eight stories plus two sentences at the bottom that do not fit yet and that I have moved to the bottom twice and keep not deleting. Writing this.

None of this moves the specific needle. But I am learning something about myself in the waiting that I did not know before, which is that I am fine at waiting when I control the next move. I am not fine at waiting when the next move belongs to someone else and there is no threshold past which I am allowed to act again. I ran out of options I built for myself. Now I am in the part of the plan that belongs to other people.

The account manager who built a whole thing out of not letting silences harden is sitting with a silence she cannot break.


Twenty-four days. Sixteen. Twenty-three left in July.

I have not asked Zoe what she thinks about any of this. She went back to her phone, and I let her.